Would it be feasible in any rocket engine (liquid or solid) intended for flight above the atmosphere to add one of the following elements: barium, lithium, sodium, copper, or calcium to create different colors in the exhaust plume, or would those elements render all engines not flight worthy?
Asked
Active
Viewed 4,088 times
9
-
1I thought Blue Origin's BE3 engine uses a copper ablative throat, which means if the engine was used as an upper stage engine, it would be introducing small amounts of copper into the exhaust, but possibly not enough to be easily seen. – May 13 '19 at 11:26
-
@JCRM I wonder if that could be an answer to What is the cause of the blue light from LH2/LOX rocket engines? – uhoh May 13 '19 at 17:25
2 Answers
15
Sure, it's entirely possible. Not unusual in model rocketry (where style points can count for something), for example:
ceejayoz
- 1,278
- 13
- 13
-
I realize I left out one very important detail in my question. Rocket engines for travel outside of the Earth's atmosphere. – Bob516 May 13 '19 at 01:57
-
7@Bob516 Doesn't really matter. Putting certain chemicals in the fuel/oxidizer can generate a colored flame. Rockets going outside the atmosphere are typically more concerned with performance than looking pretty, though. – ceejayoz May 13 '19 at 02:03
-
In the real world yes, performance is the concern. I wanted to know if in fiction it would be reasonable to consider colorful exhaust, or would it raise a red flag hurting the credibility of a story. – Bob516 May 13 '19 at 02:07
-
8In the old Lester Del Rey book "Rocket Jockey" about racing spaceships, they add chemicals to the exhaust so the spectators can differentiate the vessels. – Organic Marble May 13 '19 at 02:09
-
@Bob516 Your question might be better suited to https://worldbuilding.stackexchange.com/, in that case. – ceejayoz May 13 '19 at 02:10
-
-
3@Bob516, if you inject the colorant into the exhaust plume after the nozzle, I doubt it would have a performance impact beyond the increased mass. – Mark May 13 '19 at 03:31
-
7@Mark That mass (& assoc. hardware) could be rather significant, depending on how visible the trail needs to be. – May 13 '19 at 03:34
-
8
There are several ways to do this.
Fluorescence
Night time launch close to sunset or sunrise so that the rocket quickly reaches an altitude where it is illuminated by the Sun. The bright sunlight can then cause atoms and molecules in the plume to fluoresce, seen against a dark sky.
Keep in mind that there can be a huge amount of yellow/white blackbody radiation from soot particles in RP-1/LOX and SRB exhaust, and that could overwhelm your color effect. For more on that see What is the cause of the blue light from LH2/LOX rocket engines?
Photons in the ultraviolet component of sunlight in space are more efficient at inducing fluorescence than the UV that makes to the ground.
Some materials fluoresce nicely. Diatomic carbon or $C_2$ is famous for making comets appear green, but copper compounds are pretty common for blues and greens as well.
From this answer to In the recent Con-Ed transformer “fire”, what exactly produced the color of the huge blue glow over New York City?:
below: Vibronic spectroscopy From Spectrum_of_blue_flame
below: "C/2014 Q2 (Lovejoy) is a long-period comet discovered on 17 August 2014 by Terry Lovejoy. " Source
Below is borrowed from Why is one of these two concurrent fuel-dump spirals blue?:
above: From here
Copper sulphate solution can be stored as a liquid and easily pumped and sprayed/atomized into the plume where it would quickly disperse. However the plume would have to be hot enough to dissociate the copper atoms and excite them sufficiently to fluoresce:
Images from CNN's A transformer explosion turned the New York City skyline blue
Reflected sunlight
Night time launch close to sunset or sunrise so that the rocket quickly reaches an altitude where it is illuminated by the Sun. The bright sunlight can then reflect off of material in the plume, seen against a dark sky.
1. Glitter
Very thin, light weight, combination of plastic and other dielectric films dumped overboard at a controlled rate.
Source: New York Times What Is Glitter? A strange journey to the glitter factory. click for full size
2. Smoke
"Colored smoke is a kind of smoke created by an aerosol of small particles of a suitable pigment or dye."
uhoh
- 148,791
- 53
- 476
- 1,473
-
1I was in NYC when the transformer exploded and it was one of the eeriest things I've ever seen! – GdD May 13 '19 at 08:15
-
-
1Fluorescence and stimulated emission are very different light emission mechanisms. The former normally happens with a (Stokes or anti-Stokes) frequency shift, while the latter basically duplicates a photon. – Ruslan May 13 '19 at 15:37
-
@Ruslan you are absolutely right. I wasn't thinking, have fixed it. btw if you have any thoughts on What is the longest coherence length stimulated-emission beam demonstrated? please feel free to leave a comment or answer, it could benefit from some more attention. – uhoh May 13 '19 at 16:02
-
1
-
1