0

Imagine we have a frictionless semicircular skateboard ramp and we release a cart filled with sand from one edge of the ramp. The cart has a hole and it loses sand at a constant rate. My question is will the cart reach the other extreme edge of the ramp or will it stop midway and slide back down?

I am confused because I am not too sure whether the potential energy will constantly decrease because of decrease of mass and so it should not reach the other end

user34304
  • 1,783

1 Answers1

2

Suppose we simply your system to a cart carrying a single large grain of sand, and we drop this grain of sand off the cart at some height $h$.

We only drop the sand grain, we don't throw it, so we do no work on the sand grain and the sand grain does no work on us. That means the kinetic energy and momentum of the cart is unaffected by the sand grain. So the trajectory of the cart is unaffected by the fact we dropped the grain of sand off it. Of course, the same applies to the grain of sand: its trajectory is unaffected by the fact it's been dropped off the cart. Both the cart and sand grain carry on sliding along the ramp and they will both rise to the same height on the far side of the ramp.

The same argument applies if you drop two grains of sand, three grains of sand and indeed $n$ grains of sand for any value of $n$. In all cases the cart will reach the other extreme edge of the ramp (where it will stop then start sliding back and eventually reach its starting point).

John Rennie
  • 355,118
  • I am not able to tell which answer is correct. Any external help please? – user34304 Jan 26 '14 at 13:18
  • @user34304: two related questions are http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/91110/increase-in-velocity-by-loss-of-mass and http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/80287/time-period-of-simple-pendulum-with-varying-mass. See in particular Rody Oldenhuis's answer to the second question. Your system is not dissimilar to a pendulum. – John Rennie Jan 26 '14 at 16:14