0

Is there a law or an equation that shows which star gravity will win and suck a a planet that has 2 stars

Assume planet P has 2 stars A & B

A is smaller than B

Planet P is closer to A more than B

My question is Which Star will suck planet P into it due to gravity (Sorry if not using the right terminology)

Plant be could orbit star A or star B or it could orbit both in 8 shape

but when it is time to die, one star will be the final destination to the planet P

which one will it be?

is there a law or an equation that clarify this?

enter image description here

Qmechanic
  • 201,751
asmgx
  • 417
  • 1
    The 3 body problem is hard. AFAIK, the only figure-eight solutions require the bodies to have near-identical masses. The usual solutions for 2 stars & 1 planet have either the 2 stars close together, with the planet orbiting the pair at a distance, or have the two stars far apart, with the planet basically orbiting one of them, similar to the Sun, Moon, Earth system. – PM 2Ring Jul 09 '19 at 03:06
  • "when it is time to die, one star will be the final destination to the planet" What do you mean? Depending on how big the stars are, they might die quietly, without perturbing the planet very much. Or they could die in supernova explosions, causing all sorts of chaos. – PM 2Ring Jul 09 '19 at 03:12
  • 1
    Related: https://physics.stackexchange.com/q/31201/2451 and links therein. – Qmechanic Jul 10 '19 at 03:45

2 Answers2

2

Generally speaking, binaries cannot have shared planets orbiting at close distances. Neither dynamics nor kinematics holds.

If a binary has a common planet, the planet must be far enough, that is, the radius of the circle is large enough to be far greater than the distance between the two stars. This approximates two stars as one star at the center of mass.

The acceleration of the winding provides centripetal force, so the system can be stable. It's impossible to circle two stars at close range.

Each star of the binary can have its own planet, in this case, the planet need to close to its own star and far away to other star

Cang Ye
  • 345
  • so the planet will be ending into one star, I want to know which star will end the planet? – asmgx Jul 09 '19 at 02:56
1

It depends on exactly where the planet is, how fast it is moving, and what direction it's moving in, and there is really no one simple formula. If it is far from both stars and moving at the right speed in a direction to go around them, then it can orbit them both. But it has to be so far away that the two stars together are always close together in the sky of the planet.

Cang Ye is correct that, if the planet is close enough to one star or the other, then it can orbit just that star. For instance, Neptune is so far away that, if it were replaced by a Sun-like star, then our orbit about our sun would barely be affected. There is a concept called the "Hill sphere" that tells roughly how close you have to be to one star or the other to have a stable orbit about just that star.

If it's moving really fast, it will leave the system entirely.

If it's moving slow enough, or heading in just the right direction, it will fall into one of the stars. Rarely, orbits can be really complicated, looping around one star and then the other. Such orbits tend to be chaotic and won't last long. The planet will either fall into a star or be ejected from the system.

Oh, if one star is much bigger than the other, so that the smaller star can be said to orbit around the bigger one, then there are the five Lagrange positions that the planet can occupy, although only two of them are stable.

This is a perfect example of what is called the three body problem in physics, and it's actually been proven that there is no formula that works for all starting positions. Generally computer simulations are used if the orbit is complicated or if you are trying to analyze far into the future.

Mark Foskey
  • 3,250
  • Thanks, I am looking for a law or an equation that has the size of stars and planet the distance between plant and stars and the speed so in the end this equation could tell us what may happen to this planet – asmgx Jul 09 '19 at 04:00
  • @asmgx There is no simple law or equation. As that Wikipedia article says, there are some families of solutions to the 3 body problem, but in general the easiest way to find out what happens is to run a numerical simulation. – PM 2Ring Jul 09 '19 at 04:35
  • 1
    The planet does not have to be sucked by one of the stars. Or to fall on one of the stars. Where did you get that ideea from? – nasu Jul 09 '19 at 16:08