Detecting overshoot lines in road network (flyovers, over/underpasses) in PostGIS

Question

I'd like to know a way to detect overshoot lines (such as flyovers, over/underpasses) in road network through queries in PostGIS to validate topological connections.

This is a sample network:

CREATE TABLE net (id integer, geom geometry(MultiLineString, 4326));
INSERT INTO net (id, geom)
VALUES (1,ST_GeomFromText('MULTILINESTRING((136.63964778201967 36.58031552554121,136.64078637948796 36.57968013023401,136.6414207216891 36.579313967665655,136.64203092428795 36.578959650067986,136.6428838673968 36.57843301697034,136.6438347098042 36.577844992552514))', 4326)),
       (2,ST_GeomFromText('MULTILINESTRING((136.64039880046448 36.57933335255234,136.64078637948796 36.57968013023401,136.64119407544638 36.580076445271914,136.64165541506554 36.58051798901414))', 4326)),
       (3,ST_GeomFromText('MULTILINESTRING((136.64039880046448 36.57933335255234,136.64044439789086 36.578869185464725))', 4326)),
       (4,ST_GeomFromText('MULTILINESTRING((136.6409003730539 36.57873995108804,136.6414207216891 36.579313967665655,136.64222404380473 36.580108753416425))', 4326)),
       (5,ST_GeomFromText('MULTILINESTRING((136.6416232292288 36.57843409435816,136.64203092428795 36.578959650067986))', 4326)),
       (6,ST_GeomFromText('MULTILINESTRING((136.64203092428795 36.578959650067986,136.64244666738 36.57935489221467,136.64283290461503 36.57974259264671))', 4326)),
       (7,ST_GeomFromText('MULTILINESTRING((136.64250969906357 36.57802376968141,136.6428838673968 36.57843301697034,136.64326608196427 36.578854108330574))', 4326)),
       (8,ST_GeomFromText('MULTILINESTRING((136.64364829653186 36.577513284810436,136.6438347098042 36.577844992552514))', 4326)),
       (9,ST_GeomFromText('MULTILINESTRING((136.6438347098042 36.577844992552514,136.64412438862985 36.57833070559775))', 4326));

As illustrated in the following image, this network has 9 lines where line 2, 4 and 7 do not topologically connected to line 1. I need to generate points and export it as a new table at the corossing points of those links as shown in the right-hand side figure.

I tried to search for the solutions but could not find so far.

Actually I posted a similar question Detecting overshoot lines in road network (flyovers, over/underpasses) in QGIS but I would like to be able to manipulate it in PostGIS as well.

Answer 1

pgRouting has a comprehensive set of functions to address most of the issues you are facing, with regards to your series of questions about network topologies:

• Merging lines of which ends are not connected but close in PostGIS
• Simplifying road network with PostGIS

I'll try to answer them all with a set of queries to create a routable network for most input lineworks.

---

1. Dump your MultiLineStrings:

   A proper topology should consist of simple LineStrings - for pgRouting it is mandatory:

   CREATE TABLE <network_simple> AS (
     SELECT
       ROW_NUMBER() OVER() AS id,
       id AS old_id,
       dmp.path[1] AS old_id_seq,
       <attribute_1>,
       ...
       dmp.geom::GEOMETRY(LINESTRING, 4326) AS geom
     FROM
       <network>,
       LATERAL ST_Dump(geom) AS dmp
   );
   ALTER TABLE
     <network_simple>
     ADD PRIMARY KEY (id)
   ;
   

2. Create a noded network:

   Split the resulting linework at intersections:

   SELECT
     pgr_nodeNetwork(
       '<network_simple>',
       0.000001,
       'id',
       'geom'
     )
   ; 
   

3. Create a pgRouting topology:

   Add source/target information to your <network_simple>_noded table:

   SELECT
     pgr_createTopology(
       '<network_simple>_noded',
       0.000005,
       'geom',
       'id',
       'source',
       'target'
     )
   ;
   

---

Notes:

• the resulting network topology in <network_simple>_noded maintains a reference to <network_simple> via <network_simple>_noded.old_id = <network_simple>.id
• the gap issue is addressed by providing the tolerance parameter in pgr_createTopology; while it does not alter the geometries, it treats those within distance of the given tolerance as connected
  
  
• while it is possible to brute force a (interconnected) line merge (i.e. simplification) and noding operation via

  SELECT
    ROW_NUMBER() OVER() AS id,
    dmp.geom
  FROM
    (
      SELECT
        ST_Node(ST_LineMerge(ST_Union(geom))) AS geom
      FROM
        <network>
    ) AS nu,
    LATERAL ST_Dump(nu.geom) AS dmp
  ;
  

  you'd loose all (unique) references to your <network> table: if you are okay with that, just execute 3. from above afterwards
• if you were to run a graph contraction operation (pgr_contraction) on the <network_simple>_noded, you would likely solve the gaps and line merge issues, but you have to be aware that this algorithm is meant for edge/vertex compression, and the resulting topology would likely not look like your input network due to altered edges

Answer 2

If your question is as in your title, you just want to detect the lines intersected by line 1 (but not the ones just touching it) :

SELECT a.*
FROM net a, net b
WHERE a.id != 1 AND b.id = 1 AND ST_Intersects(a.geom, b.geom)
   AND ST_Touches(a.geom, b.geom) IS NOT TRUE

If you want to generate points on theses intersections as shown in your image, you have to extract a point (ST_CollectionExtract(geom,1)) from the intersection of the lines (ST_Intersection(line1,line2))

SELECT ST_CollectionExtract(ST_Intersection(a.geom, b.geom),1) as geom
FROM net a, net b
WHERE a.id != 1 AND b.id = 1 AND ST_Intersects(a.geom, b.geom)
   AND ST_Touches(a.geom, b.geom) IS NOT TRUE

Answer 3

ST_Crosses tests if two lines cross rather than touch. This can be run to check all unordered pairs using a "triangle join". The intersection point is computed with ST_Intersection.

WITH data(id, geom) AS (VALUES
  (1,ST_GeomFromText('MULTILINESTRING((136.63964778201967 36.58031552554121,136.64078637948796 36.57968013023401,136.6414207216891 36.579313967665655,136.64203092428795 36.578959650067986,136.6428838673968 36.57843301697034,136.6438347098042 36.577844992552514))', 4326)),
  (2,ST_GeomFromText('MULTILINESTRING((136.64039880046448 36.57933335255234,136.64078637948796 36.57968013023401,136.64119407544638 36.580076445271914,136.64165541506554 36.58051798901414))', 4326)),
  (3,ST_GeomFromText('MULTILINESTRING((136.64039880046448 36.57933335255234,136.64044439789086 36.578869185464725))', 4326)),
  (4,ST_GeomFromText('MULTILINESTRING((136.6409003730539 36.57873995108804,136.6414207216891 36.579313967665655,136.64222404380473 36.580108753416425))', 4326)),
  (5,ST_GeomFromText('MULTILINESTRING((136.6416232292288 36.57843409435816,136.64203092428795 36.578959650067986))', 4326)),
  (6,ST_GeomFromText('MULTILINESTRING((136.64203092428795 36.578959650067986,136.64244666738 36.57935489221467,136.64283290461503 36.57974259264671))', 4326)),
  (7,ST_GeomFromText('MULTILINESTRING((136.64250969906357 36.57802376968141,136.6428838673968 36.57843301697034,136.64326608196427 36.578854108330574))', 4326)),
  (8,ST_GeomFromText('MULTILINESTRING((136.64364829653186 36.577513284810436,136.6438347098042 36.577844992552514))', 4326)),
  (9,ST_GeomFromText('MULTILINESTRING((136.6438347098042 36.577844992552514,136.64412438862985 36.57833070559775))', 4326))
)
SELECT a.id, b.id, ST_Intersection(a.geom, b.geom) AS geom 
FROM data a
JOIN data b ON ST_Intersects(a.geom, b.geom)
WHERE a.id < b.id AND ST_Crosses(a.geom, b.geom);

See also this answer: https://gis.stackexchange.com/a/431247/14766