My goal is to create a .shp file in CRS EPSG 4326 - WGS 84 of land cover data for several counties in California. My idea is to use the NLCD 2016 dataset in QGIS to convert it into the desired shapefile. However, when I try to set all layers to WGS 84 (simply by clicking properties->source->and changing the drop down CRS (ignoring the warning that this will not change the original data)), the resulting image looks like this:
How can I get the NLCD data to overlay the OpenStreet basemap (set to WGS 84 in same manner as NLCD raster) correctly?

