Which of these spices do not lose their tang when heated/boiled?

Question

I was looking to substitute chilli for some non capsaicin containing spices.

The best items I can up with was paprika, cumin, black pepper, ancho chillies and oregano.

Initially I tried black pepper and realised it loses its tang when cooking and so it must be used at the end as a raw ingredient which is not what I want.

What other items in this list would lose their spice potency like black pepper when cooked. I’m trying to remove those items so I can use one for cooking as would be the case with chilli.

As bob1 has pointed out -- two of those will have capsaicin. And as for 'tang', I generally go with sour things. (sumac, tamarind, a splash of vinegar, etc.) — Joe, Oct 31 '19 at 23:45
@Rob UK and US English are equally acceptable. If you edit, leave the author's choice intact. — Cascabel, Nov 03 '19 at 03:54
My experience with black pepper is the opposite. I usually add it toward the end because I have accidentally added too much black pepper in the past, resulting in overspiced dishes as the pepper infuses during cooking. Then again, I sometimes use a lot of pepper. It's true that black pepper will lose its complexity of flavor during cooking, which is another reason I typically add it toward the end. But on multiple occasions I've accidentally produced dishes that were almost too "peppery" to eat by adding too much pepper at the outset. — Athanasius, Nov 03 '19 at 14:35

score 4 · Answer 1 · answered Oct 31 '19 at 23:27

Paprika and ancho chillies are both from the same family as the hotter peppers and often contain capsaicin, though this depends exactly on which paprika you have.

Cumin and oregano (and black pepper) are all from other families. I would not rate cumin or oregano as spicy in terms of heat, although cumin can enhance heat when consumed with it. Oregano is the main herb flavour you will find in pasta sauces like bolognese. Cumin is the predominant flavor in many dishes from Mexican/central American and Indian cuisines - if you are making "chili con carne" this is likely a spice you use already. Both of these retain flavour when cooked.

For some non-capsaicin containing alternatives see answers in this thread

also this one : https://cooking.stackexchange.com/q/64382/67 — Joe, Oct 31 '19 at 23:42

score 4 · Accepted Answer · answered Oct 31 '19 at 23:31

I'm not exactly clear about what you are asking. Technically speaking, they are not all spices. Paprika and ancho are dried and ground peppers (though you can certainly get whole ancho). When cooked they will rehydrate somewhat and the flavor will become more integrated into the dish. Oregano is an herb. It will not fade, or go bitter, as much as black pepper when cooked, but there is certainly a difference between dried and fresh herbs. Cumin seed is the only "spice" on your list. It's flavor will certainly persist in cooked food.

Which of these spices do not lose their tang when heated/boiled?

2 Answers2