Drawbacks of the Pomodoro method

1

1

No one likes procrastination, or at least the idea of it.

So I decided, for this summer, to let it go. To take premeditated walks instead of watching random youtube videos. To break my work time into 20 minute chunks, to match the human attention span. It sounded like the productive, utopian dream of any hardworking student. Everything seemed fine at first. But after a few weeks my mind began to resist me, resenting my efforts to focus it, and I garnered increasing stress, and misery. Not one to give up, I supposed: my mind was just naturally trying to preserve itself against the onslaught. I therefore introduced lengthier walks, and took longer showers, to allow my mind to recuperate.

And everything seemed fine again. I was able to complete my schedules without my brain hurting, without unhealthy stress. But there is one more issue that remains, that I am coming to grips with: Everything was mechanical: the timers, the premeditated nature of the whole process. Sometimes my schedule would tell me to stop working and preserve my mind, just as I was getting into the thick of things, denying me the intellectual pleasure, and other times, it would be the opposite: I would be in a work period, violently struggling to keep my mind from zoning out.

Worst of all, because of this micromanagement, I was living life in the third person. I wasn't experiencing it first hand. I now call that the "lost summer". Once I realized this, I jettisoned the timers - I felt spontaneous again. I came up with incredibly creative ideas - my mind wandered, and it was a liberating freedom.

I feel like working under a timer does sharpen your focus - however, aren't there modes of thought which the pomodoro method is suppressing (i.e. creative, spontaneous thinking, where one is not so self-aware)? Moreover, don't these micromanaging tools prevent us from experiencing life?

Does anyone have any ideas on how to balance the pomodoro method with perhaps something else?

David Roberts

Posted 2014-11-25T05:44:36.250

Reputation: 108

Question was closed 2014-11-25T15:19:29.463

Answers

0

Not everything worth doing is worth overdoing.

What happened to you is you've found that running is good. And you decided to become Forrest Gump in hist best years.

There is a common misconception that the goal of time management techniques is to enable you be super-productive round the clock. That is not true.

"Work smarter, not harder" is a good thing. If use better action or time management methods enables you to do most of your tasks in 5 hours instead of 10, it does not mean that you should try to cram twice more stuff in 10 hours. That said, it is usually a good idea to put some more stuff on your plate. But wisely.

Good self-management approach is similar to a secure base (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attachment_theory#Secure_attachment). Having it allows you to eafely embark on your creative search journeys.

Whatever method you choose (pomodoro or something else) - do not overdo it. When you are comfortable with the pace you're going with, make only slight tweaks. Spend the rest of your time exploring new ideas and things.

P.S. question title can be slightly misleading - what you've described is not a drawback of the method, it is a result of your implementation.

Alex Leonov

Posted 2014-11-25T05:44:36.250

Reputation: 714